My Favorite Restaurants on Catalina Island

During my cruise on Navigator of the Seas I had the opportunity to spend a full day exploring Catalina Island. Since I was there for the entire day, I decided to enjoy all my meals on the island and discover some of the best local spots. Here are my top picks for the best places to eat on Catalina Island, along with a must-try dish at each spot. restaurant catalina island

Breakfast: Original Jack's Country Kitchen

Start your day at Original Jack’s Country Kitchen, a beloved local diner known for its comforting breakfast options and friendly service. The cozy atmosphere makes it the perfect place to fuel up before exploring the island.

Must-Try Dish: Cinnamon Roll French Toast – Thick slices of cinnamon roll, grilled to perfection, and topped with powdered sugar and syrup.

Lunch: The Lobster Trap

For lunch, head over to The Lobster Trap, a casual seafood restaurant known for its fresh seafood this spot is a favorite among both locals and visitors.

Must-Try Dish: Lobster Tacos – Fresh, buttery lobster served on warm tortillas with a tasty coleslaw and just a little bit of spice.

Dessert: Catalina Cones restaurant catalina island

This small ice cream shop is a great spot to cool off while walking along Avalon’s waterfront.

Must-Try Treat: Salted Caramel Ice Cream – Creamy caramel ice cream with a pinch of sea salt.

Island Donuts

Want a sweet treat with a coffee before heading back to the ship? Stop by Island Donuts, a hidden treasure offering some of the best donuts on the island.

Must-Try Treat: Blueberry Donut